|
Dilbert takes a dig at IIT
By PRIYA GANAPATI
in Bangalore
India Abroad - September 26, 2003
© 2003
India Abroad /
rediff.com Inc. All Rights
Reserved.
Excerpts from
article - the full text is in copies of India Abroad on the
newsstand.
The Indian Institute of Technology
has found fame in an unlikely place: Scott Adam’s comic strip,
Dilbert. On the morning of September 15, readers across America woke
up to find Asok a character on Dilbert, talking about his IIT
credentials. Soon the IIT networks started buzzing with the news and
e-mails flew forwarding the strip to friends and colleagues. ‘It’s a
recognition of how much ‘Brand IIT’ has penetrated the consciousness
of America!’ the e-mails gushed, while others wrote that it was an
'insidious' American plot to portray Indians and IIT in a 'negative
and condescending light'. Either way, Dilbert has put IIT in the
limelight again. According to the Dilbert web site, Asok
(pronounced ah-shook) was introduced to satisfy the hordes of
interns who wrote to request their own character. ‘Asok is
brilliant, but as an intern he is immensely naive about the
cruelties and politics of the business world. His name is a common
one in India (but usually spelled Ashok),’ says the site. Asok has
now been turned into an IIT graduate and will be on the strip all
week long.
Over the last three years, IIT has
gathered a huge amount of international media coverage. Recently
CBS 60 Minutes featured IITs in which anchor Leslie Stahl said, ‘Put
Harvard, MIT and Princeton together, and you begin to get an idea of
the status of this school’.
...
...
...
A BusinessWeek cover story about
the IITs, headlined ‘Whiz Kids’, was one of the early branding
events that began to build a popular perception of IIT-ians as
super- stars. Over the years, a number of other articles appeared in
the business press, including cover stories in Forbes on Vinod
Khosia as the uber-VC, and ‘Technical Sutra’ in Salon magazine. The
media attention was not restricted to the US; RAI, the Italian
network, did a story in Italian about the IITs a few years ago.
“Today, the IIT brand stands for
‘excellence, innovation and leadership. The perception ception of
people across the globe, whether in India, in the US or elsewhere,
is that the IIT system produces highly talented professionals, who
have both the ability and the self-confidence to reach for success,”
says Ram Kelkar, an alumnus of IIT Bombay.
However, others are unwilling to be
as gung-ho as Kelkar about the appearance of IIT on the cartoon
strip. They say the cartoon strip reinforces the stereotype of
IIT-ians as nerds who work too much and have too little fun. For
instance, m the first strip, when asked if he is tired after doing
all the work himself Asok deadpans, ‘I am trained to sleep only on
national holidays.’
“IIT has got quite a bit of
recognition outside. Still the way it is being portrayed in the
strip is wrong. We are not super humans. We are not weird people.
We study hard and have lots of fun too," saysGaurav Porwal,
Secretary (Cultural Affairs) at IIT Bombay.
The appearance of Asok as an IIT
graduate m the strip is being seen as coinciding with the wave of
anti-outsourcing sentiment that a section of America is currently in
the grip of.
Recently, a number of bills
demanding that the federal government not outsource IT projects and
also put a cap on the number of visas issued to foreign technology
workers have been proposed.
“American workers are scared of
losing their Jobs to people from India. Considering the mileage
that IIT has got in recent times, it is clear that through the strip
they are trying to make fun of Indians,” says a professor from IIT
Bombay who did not want to be identified.
Few other Indian institutes have
captured popular imagination in the US like the IITs. Part of the
credit goes to IIT-ians who have worked hard to build their
institution in a global brand. For instance, the IIT Bombay
Heritage Fund, along with others, has a committee that looks into
brand building.
“It has surely helped that some of
our most prominent alumni, including Victor Menezes who is the
Co-Chair of our Board, encouraged us from very early on to focus our
efforts on branding, drawing inspiration from the way they built
their own global brands like Citibank," says Kelkar.
And for this set, being on the
Dilbert strip is not such a negative thing after all.
“The IIT brand has surely arrived.
We are featured on Dilbert and even if it is in a satirical tone, it
still says a lot about how much Brand IIT has penetrated the
consciousness of America,” says Kelkar. |